Fifth Circuit Rules Second Amendment Protects Firearm Sales in Major Federal Gun Case
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit delivered a significant victory for the Second Amendment on November 19, ruling that the constitutional right to keep and bear arms also protects the sale of firearms. The decision rejects the notion that the federal government can regulate firearm commerce without implicating the constitutional rights of gun owners, buyers, and sellers.
In United States v. Deare, No. 24-30241, a three-judge panel vacated a lower court’s decision denying a constitutional challenge to federal firearms-dealer licensing requirements and sent the case back for further proceedings. Although the ruling does not invalidate federal dealer-licensing laws, it establishes an important constitutional principle: The Second Amendment’s protections extend beyond simply possessing and carrying firearms.
“The plain text of the Second Amendment covers the sale of firearms,” the court declared in its published opinion.
Perhaps even more revealing, the federal government conceded during oral arguments that the Second Amendment applies to the commercial sale of firearms. That concession, combined with the court’s holding, undercuts the argument that restrictions on firearm transactions can automatically escape constitutional scrutiny merely because Congress characterizes them as commercial regulations.
Federal Firearms Prosecution Leads to Second Amendment Challenge
The case centers on Jeremiah Micah Deare, who was indicted in the Western District of Louisiana for conspiracy to engage in the business of dealing firearms without a federal firearms license (FFL), in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 922(a)(1). He also faced charges involving false statements concerning the records of federally licensed firearms dealers.
Deare challenged the constitutionality of the federal licensing requirement and related record-keeping provisions, arguing that they violated the Second Amendment. The district court rejected his challenge, concluding that licensing and record-keeping requirements did not implicate the right to keep and bear arms because they regulated commercial activity rather than firearm possession.
The district court also concluded that the licensing requirements were consistent with the nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation. Deare subsequently went to trial, where a jury convicted him on all counts. He received a sentence of 97 months in federal prison.
On appeal, Deare argued that the lower court had incorrectly excluded firearm sales from the Second Amendment’s protections. The Fifth Circuit agreed that the constitutional analysis could not end simply because the challenged provisions regulated firearm commerce.
Citing its earlier decision in Reese v. ATF, the court explained that the right to possess firearms necessarily includes the ability to acquire them. The appellate judges therefore vacated the district court’s denial of Deare’s motion to dismiss and remanded the case for additional proceedings.

